You Earned a Ticket!

Which school do you want to support?

Lesson 8.2

Education Dollars:
What They Buy

If you compare school budgets, don’t forget to compare this…

hero image

As discussed in the previous lesson, funding for public education is a smaller slice of the economy in California than in other states. In terms of plain old dollars per student, California is about average.

This is very bad news for California students, because money is only good for what it can buy.

Money is only good for what it can buy

California is an expensive place to run a school. Most of the costs of a school are people costs such as salaries, benefits and pensions, which cost more in California than in other states. That means California school districts can afford less of everything that matters most — such as teachers, school leaders, counselors, aides, and support staff.

Most spending is for instruction Source: LAO. Click image for the full report.

Because California is a high-wage, high-cost-of-living state, education dollars don’t go as far here as they do elsewhere. For example, the cost of living in Texas and Florida is much lower than in California, which enables teacher salaries to be lower there. Other high-wage, high-cost states such as New York, Connecticut, New Jersey and Massachusetts invest considerably more per student than California does.

The student-teacher ratio in California is much higher than in the rest of the US

There are different ways of ranking the states in terms of their investment in education, but the rankings that matter most are those that compare purchasing power. In the ways that matter for students, California's schools are very lean. This is a high-cost state, but it funds education as if it were a low-cost state.

Fewer Adults

The math is Unavoidable. Higher salaries and less money to pay for them means California children have a lot fewer teachers involved in their education. It's a big gap.

It's not just about teacher ratios, either. California compares unfavorably with other states in terms of the presence of adult professionals, period. For example, in 2018-2019 California’s student-to-school-counselor ratio was 612-to-1, ranked 46th in the US according to a report from American School Counselor Association.

Too much bureaucracy? Actually, California has significantly fewer administrators per student than average.

Skeptics sometimes assume that California schools and districts are administration-heavy, but they are mistaken. California laws restrict the number of administrators a district may employ. Overall, California's schools and districts are supported by significantly fewer administrators per student than the national average. In fact, one theme of the Getting Down to Facts II studies is that a lack of leadership in California's schools can cause harm.

Comparing resources in schools, 2018-19

  California Rest of USA California rank
Students per teacher 23.1 15.3 2nd worst in USA
Students per guidance counselor 613 412 5th worst in USA
Students per administrator* 285 180 4th worst in USA

*Includes both school and district administrators

What is an adequate education?

In many states, education advocates have turned to the judicial branch of government to make the case for more funding for education. Some state constitutions explicitly or implicitly require their school system to provide students at least an adequate education. Litigation, or the threat of it, has compelled some states to increase spending on education, but California's courts declined to follow their lead.

The question is meaningful, anyway. What resources do schools actually need in order to provide students with an adequate basic level of education?

The 2018 report What Does It Cost to Educate California’s Students takes a bottom-up approach to the question, following the example of litigation in other states. The study, part of the "Getting Down to Facts II" project, consulted multiple expert panels to estimate the necessary staff and services required for a California middle school. Below is a summary, reflecting the panel's advice that schools serving students with higher needs require additional resources.

In the chart above, the stacked bar on the left represents the expert panel’s assessment of adequate expenditures for a basic middle school: about $13,000 per average pupil in 2016 dollars, not counting pension expenses. 

Most schools in California do not fit this profile, the panel noted. Most have needs beyond the basic profile because they have many students in poverty and many students learning English. The panel estimated that the per-pupil cost to provide these students with an adequate education was much higher — in the range of over $16,800. The study concluded that California would need to increase funding by about 32 per cent to equip schools with resources adequate to take on the goals set by the State Board of Education.

The expert panel recommended the resources and ratios below as a minimum definition of adequate staff and services for a middle school. Note that these estimates do not address rising costs related to the teacher pension system, a major category of ongoing expense for the state, school districts, and teachers themselves. The pension system is explained in Lesson 3.11.

Core Instruction

Seven periods a day AND two periods for planning and collaboration among teachers.

An average class size of 22 students for the core subjects (i.e., English language arts, Math, and Science). This excludes resource teachers or teachers supporting special education and English learner students. Once these additional instructors are considered the estimated pupil–teacher ratio is 15:1.

Special Populations

One or two English language specialists, as well as two educational assistants to support new students who are classified as ELs.

Small caseloads for special education staff: up to 7 students with high-severity disabilities per educational specialist, and 17 students with low-severity disabilities per educational specialist.

Student and Other Support

About 10 more instructional and pupil support staff for a typical middle school with 609 students.

Professional development opportunities for staff, including in-house programs as well as funds for teachers to attend conferences.

Extended Day and Year

Smaller class sizes in the extended time programs (compared to the core program class sizes), reducing the pupil–teacher ratio from 30:1 to 18:1.

All students with severe disabilities enrolled in special education to attend summer school.

Parent groups, local education foundations, and philanthropists in California try valiantly to support their schools with fundraising of many types. But you can't bake-sale your way out of an operating gap of this magnitude.

The next two lessons explain the sources of school funding in California and how the state got into its current situation.

Updated August 2017, March 2018, November 2018, October 2019, January 2021

Review

California has the highest student/teacher ratio of any state in America. There are many reasons. Which of the following explanations is NOT true?

Answer the question correctly and earn a ticket.
Learn More

Questions & Comments

To comment or reply, please sign in .

user avatar
Vik November 5, 2017 at 11:13 pm
This is an injustice to our future generations.
user avatar
Elizabeth Perkins October 27, 2017 at 5:06 pm
24 - 26 in K-2, 30 in 3, 4, 5
user avatar
Caryn-C September 11, 2017 at 11:33 am
Honestly, I found these statistics horrifying. 22.1 students to each teacher? That went away years ago. At our K-8, the numbers are much closer to 30+.

It is interesting to view the issue in terms of California being a high wage, high cost of living state. Well, so is New York and they are investing almost double in their students? Pretty embarrassing.
user avatar
Esmeralda Munoz April 29, 2020 at 1:36 pm
True! I hate when they say 22 students to 1 teacher. Big fat lie!
user avatar
ed August 27, 2016 at 11:51 pm
A new mantra for California:
Making better with less
user avatar
Brandi Galasso May 2, 2015 at 4:15 pm
The students need more people to directly effect and help them learn and experience. Not people paid to keep saying what they need instead of doing what they need.
user avatar
Tay Fe April 24, 2015 at 9:54 am
California public schools need to return to 20 to 1 in elementary and have smaller class sizes in 7 to 12.
user avatar
Veli Waller April 10, 2015 at 8:22 pm
Our elementary school of over 800 students just got a counselor - 2 days a week. Nice to see something positive like this. The graphs and statistics in this lesson are horrifying. California last in the country in all of these key areas.
©2003-2021 Jeff Camp
Design by SimpleSend

Sharing is caring!

Password Reset

Change your mind? Sign In.

Search all lesson and blog content here.

Welcome Back!

Login with Email

We will send your Login Link to your email
address. Click on the link and you will be
logged into Ed100. No more passwords to
remember!

Share via Email

Get on Board!
Learn how California's School System works so you can make a difference.
Our free lessons are short, easy to read, and up to date. Each lesson you complete earns a ticket for your school. You could win $1,000 for your PTA.

Join Ed100

Already a member? Login

Or Create Account