You Earned a Ticket!

Which school do you want to support?

Lesson 7.6

Initiatives and Education:
Power to the People?

The ultimate wildcard in California education policy is…

hero image

Image: Petition clipboards CC Neon Tommy

California’s powerful initiative process was added to the state constitution in 1911. With enough signatures, your idea for change to California law or even the California constitution can be placed on a statewide ballot.

Paid signatures dominate the initiative process

Your name
on that petition
for the sake
of future scholars
scored the earnest
clipboard dude
a couple
hard-earned dollars

In principle, the initiative process is about private citizens. In practice, collecting signatures that actually matter is very directly a function of dollars. Virtually all signatures for successful initiative petitions are collected by paid signature-gatherers, who typically earn $1 to $3 for each valid signature on their clipboard. (Have you noticed how genuinely they smile when you sign?) The signature collection cost of an initiative in California can be several million dollars.

AB 857 (vetoed by Governor Brown in 2013) was one of several efforts to reduce the power of money to put an initiative on the ballot. This measure would have required at least ten percent of qualified signatures to be collected by volunteers.

The California Secretary of State provides directions for qualifying an initiative.

During the 2016 election season the Sacramento Bee featured a recorded phone call to signature gatherers with an update on the price being offered for signatures on various measures.

With a majority vote, initiatives can directly amend the state constitution, bypassing the legislative process. When lawmakers want to change the state constitution they also have to get voter approval. To walk in the weeds about the difference between an initiative (which bypasses the legislature) and a referendum (placed on the ballot by the legislature) read here.

Prop 13 and more

Initiatives have had an enormous impact on public schools in California. The most famous initiative was Proposition 13. Popular from the moment of its creation, Proposition 13 demonstrated the potential scope of initiative power in 1978. The main appeal of the measure was to limit property taxes but the net effect was to cut the level of school support that came from local property taxes and hand the control of school funding to the state.

In the years that followed Proposition 13′s passage, voters grew frustrated with falling school budgets, which they blamed on legislative failure. Another initiative, Proposition 98, promised to put a floor under funding for K-12 schools and community colleges. Prop 98 established a complex formula obligating the legislature to allocate a certain amount of the budget for the support of the education system. (See Chapter 8 for more on the effect of these propositions.)

Other initiatives have had enormous impact on education in California. For example:

  • 1984: Proposition 37 created the State Lottery, specifying that 34% of earnings would be earmarked for public education (which amounts to about one cent out of every dollar that goes to schools).
  • 1990: Proposition 111 amended Proposition 98.
  • 1998: Proposition 227 limited non-English instruction. (Repealed in 2016 by proposition 58.)
  • 2000: Proposition 39, placed on the ballot by the Legislature, amended a part of Proposition 13 and enabled school districts to pass General Obligation bonds with a 55% vote.

Big Ballots

In more recent years, Governors Arnold Schwarzenegger and Jerry Brown also made use of the initiative process. While Schwarzenegger was unsuccessful in gaining voter support for his desired reforms, Brown managed to get voters to raise state income and sales taxes in 2012 in order to stabilize the state budget with passage of Proposition 30.

100 years of initiatives in California. Few petitions end up on the ballot; Even fewer pass into law. 100 years of initiatives in California. Few petitions end up on the ballot; Even fewer pass into law.

These powerful governors turned to initiatives rather than the legislature because the legislative process had proved insurmountable. Important policy in this state is frequently enacted through the ballot. The dominant role of initiatives in California’s tortured education system has helped to prompt some thoughtful reflection about whether the initiative system is due for a tune-up. In 2013, the Public Policy Institute of California released a study that looked at public opinion about initiatives and made policy recommendations.

Initiatives, changes in law and other efforts don't arise spontaneously. The next lesson examines the ecosystem of organizations that variously support, inform, critique and cajole to create changes in the system.

Review

For an initiative to be placed on the ballot in California, a large number of voter signatures must be gathered. Most measures don't qualify for the ballot. For measures that DO qualify, what portion of signatures are typically collected by paid signature-gatherers?

Answer the question correctly and earn a ticket.
Learn More

Questions & Comments

To comment or reply, please sign in .

©2003-2017 Jeff Camp
design by SimpleSend, build by modern interface

Sharing is caring!

Password Reset

Change your mind? Sign In.

Search all lesson and blog content here.

Sign In

Not a member? Join now.

or via email

Share via Email

Join Ed100

Already Joined Ed100? Sign In.

or via email